| Rank | Who | Time |
| 4 Undisclosed Strategists | ||
| 5. | kantgant | 15 seconds |
| 6. | Quam | 16 seconds |
| 3 Mysterious Riddlers | ||
| 10. | TX101010 | 19 seconds |
| 11. | offput | 19 seconds |
| 12. | eltsac | 19 seconds |
| Shadow Riddler | ||
| 14. | TomFrog | 20 seconds |
| Undisclosed Gamer | ||
| 16. | rfegley | 21 seconds |
| 5 Unsubscribed Achievers | ||
| 22. | ggodwin | 24 seconds |
| 23. | liqrtech | 24 seconds |
| 2 Stealth Challengers | ||
| 26. | reaganmesser | 25 seconds |
| 4 Stealth Strategists | ||
| 31. | juri | 27 seconds |
| 6 Anonymous Riddlers | ||
| 38. | sem | 29 seconds |
| 8 Non-Paying Gamers | ||
| 47. | jonny | 32 seconds |
| 5 Anonymous Achievers | ||
| 53. | Amj501 | 33 seconds |
| 54. | mdrichard05 | 33 seconds |
| 3 Shadow Enthusiasts | ||
| 58. | charlesa | 34 seconds |
| 2 Free Explorers | ||
| 61. | Bigmike | 35 seconds |
| 62. | pikapikapi | 35 seconds |
| 63. | iayork | 35 seconds |
| 64. | dnwlf | 35 seconds |
| 2 Shadow Victors | ||
| 67. | Ianc | 36 seconds |
| 4 Unidentified Achievers | ||
| 72. | Andrew Kemp | 37 seconds |
| 73. | some chap | 37 seconds |
| 4 Visiting Achievers | ||
| 78. | Banstyle | 39 seconds |
| 2 Non-Member Victors | ||
| 81. | rlivsey | 40 seconds |
| 24 Unregistered Strategists | ||
| 106. | rawrdimus | 47 seconds |
| 107. | crossjam | 47 seconds |
| 108. | dsheneman | 47 seconds |
| 7 Incognito Challengers | ||
| 116. | MrMumbly | 49 seconds |
| 3 Stealth Riddlers | ||
| 120. | rellim | 50 seconds |
| 121. | kennethson | 50 seconds |
| 10 Secret Solvers | ||
| 132. | JeremyK | 55 seconds |
| 21 Hidden Contestants | ||
| 154. | gwbattershill | 1 minute, 6 seconds |
| 13 Unidentified Achievers | ||
| 168. | dotcom | 1 minute, 10 seconds |
| 8 Non-Paying Thinkers | ||
| 177. | scottaw | 1 minute, 16 seconds |
| 6 Unidentified Thinkers | ||
| 184. | AirSpencer | 1 minute, 20 seconds |
| 4 Unidentified Enthusiasts | ||
| 189. | bumblefett | 1 minute, 23 seconds |
| 3 Mysterious Achievers | ||
| 193. | Aaron915 | 1 minute, 26 seconds |
| 4 Non-Paying Gamers | ||
| 198. | BWII | 1 minute, 29 seconds |
| 3 Non-Member Victors | ||
| 202. | erdoc | 1 minute, 32 seconds |
| 203. | AGS | 1 minute, 33 seconds |
| 4 Mystery Competitors | ||
| 208. | peezismyname | 1 minute, 36 seconds |
| 209. | JSlo | 1 minute, 37 seconds |
| Unknown Adventurer | ||
| 211. | Galadriel | 1 minute, 40 seconds |
| 4 Non-Paying Gamers | ||
| 216. | leoncowle | 1 minute, 49 seconds |
| 2 Stealth Challengers | ||
| 219. | brianstorm | 1 minute, 50 seconds |
| 8 Anonymous Gamers | ||
| 228. | Mark S | 2 minutes, 3 seconds |
| 3 Stealth Riddlers | ||
| 232. | greermama | 2 minutes, 12 seconds |
| 20 Secret Players | ||
| 253. | jsuttonmorse | 2 minutes, 51 seconds |
| 8 Shadow Enthusiasts | ||
| 262. | sjcarter@mac.com | 3 minutes, 24 seconds |
| 5 Incognito Solvers | ||
| 268. | musubi | 3 minutes, 52 seconds |
| 17 Mystery Adventurers | ||
| 286. | ReddyEddy | 6 minutes, 9 seconds |
| 18 Secret Achievers | ||
| 305. | Ambiverbal | 11 minutes, 55 seconds |
| 5 Visiting Challengers | ||
| 311. | sepcot 👑 | 22 minutes, 47 seconds |
| 312. | mccllstr | 25 minutes, 39 seconds |
| 2 Incognito Competitors | ||
| 315. | Rdickers23 | 2 hours, 1 minute, 33 seconds |
| 316. | w00zy | 2 hours, 25 minutes, 7 seconds |
| Visiting Riddler | ||
| 318. | RickG | 4 hours, 26 minutes, 24 seconds |
| 4 Non-Member Contestants | ||
| 323. | robbinamsterdam | 746 hours, 51 minutes, 46 seconds |