| Rank | Who | Time |
| Visiting Riddler | ||
| 2. | tylerb ⭐ | 32 seconds |
| 3. | Spol ⭐ | 33 seconds |
| 4. | kricket5687 ⭐ | 38 seconds |
| 3 Mysterious Players | ||
| 8. | raccoona | 43 seconds |
| 5 Anonymous Competitors | ||
| 14. | dbergey | 45 seconds |
| 15. | abrahamvegh ⭐ | 45 seconds |
| 4 Mystery Solvers | ||
| 20. | aburtch | 47 seconds |
| 8 Secret Challengers | ||
| 29. | jsuttonmorse ⭐ | 53 seconds |
| Mystery Enthusiast | ||
| 31. | jnassi | 54 seconds |
| 4 Incognito Gamers | ||
| 36. | k._pow ⭐ | 55 seconds |
| Incognito Gamer | ||
| 38. | MsKinNJ | 56 seconds |
| 39. | mrflip | 56 seconds |
| 40. | robbinamsterdam ⭐ | 56 seconds |
| 2 Stealth Contestants | ||
| 43. | BenRiceM | 57 seconds |
| 44. | iayork | 57 seconds |
| 13 Shadow Riddlers | ||
| 58. | Essiek55 | 1 minute, 3 seconds |
| 4 Anonymous Enthusiasts | ||
| 63. | glucas | 1 minute, 7 seconds |
| 64. | kantgant | 1 minute, 7 seconds |
| Stealth Gamer | ||
| 66. | LaurenSKF | 1 minute, 11 seconds |
| 4 Incognito Puzzlers | ||
| 71. | billo | 1 minute, 19 seconds |
| 72. | bflock ⭐ | 1 minute, 20 seconds |
| 6 Mystery Explorers | ||
| 79. | WLG | 1 minute, 22 seconds |
| 2 Unregistered Victors | ||
| 82. | adamqp | 1 minute, 23 seconds |
| 7 Non-Paying Strategists | ||
| 90. | greermama | 1 minute, 26 seconds |
| 2 Incognito Competitors | ||
| 93. | Tyger | 1 minute, 29 seconds |
| 94. | seanl ⭐ | 1 minute, 29 seconds |
| 95. | agiletortoise | 1 minute, 30 seconds |
| 7 Stealth Players | ||
| 103. | Jono | 1 minute, 36 seconds |
| Hidden Riddler | ||
| 105. | GrokTime ⭐ | 1 minute, 38 seconds |
| 106. | JeremyK | 1 minute, 38 seconds |
| 5 Secret Participants | ||
| 112. | joekissell ⭐ | 1 minute, 40 seconds |
| 2 Secret Puzzlers | ||
| 115. | dmoren | 1 minute, 42 seconds |
| 116. | BooBooBot | 1 minute, 42 seconds |
| 5 Unregistered Contestants | ||
| 122. | haugen ⭐ | 1 minute, 51 seconds |
| 6 Mysterious Challengers | ||
| 129. | TLee64 | 1 minute, 58 seconds |
| 3 Mysterious Enthusiasts | ||
| 133. | Bigmike ⭐ | 2 minutes, 4 seconds |
| 134. | solar | 2 minutes, 5 seconds |
| 135. | Grumpy | 2 minutes, 7 seconds |
| 6 Non-Member Adventurers | ||
| 142. | Andrew Kemp | 2 minutes, 10 seconds |
| Mystery Competitor | ||
| 144. | eltsac ⭐ | 2 minutes, 16 seconds |
| 2 Non-Paying Adventurers | ||
| 147. | kelan ⭐ | 2 minutes, 22 seconds |
| 148. | nathanjliu 👑 | 2 minutes, 31 seconds |
| 4 Unknown Victors | ||
| 153. | Sierra | 2 minutes, 59 seconds |
| Unknown Strategist | ||
| 155. | yatil | 3 minutes, 22 seconds |
| 6 Non-Member Participants | ||
| 162. | nibeck | 5 minutes, 1 second |
| 163. | heyitsdiggy | 6 minutes, 16 seconds |
| 164. | Ianc ⭐ | 11 minutes, 21 seconds |
| 2 Mysterious Competitors | ||
| 167. | Dr. Ferrous | 461 hours, 45 minutes, 7 seconds |